An Oceanside man who thought he was responding to a Craigslist ad for sex with a woman stabbed another man in his Mission Viejo apartment after discovering that the man had been masquerading as a woman online, a prosecutor said Wednesday.
The prosecution alleges that Ingala-Whiting killed Bonomolo after he was deceived in a Craigslist sex ad. The defense maintains that Ingala-Whiting killed Bonomolo in self-defense after Bonomolo tried to rape him. Ingala-Whiting responded, unaware that Jeanie and the boyfriend were actually just one man — Bonomolo, Pino said.
In corresponding with Jeanie, Ingala-Whiting indicated that had never been with a man before but was interested in experimenting with the couple, Pino said. The prosecutor said Ingala-Whiting suffered a cut to his hand as he stabbed Bonomolo more than 14 times.
Authorities also tied him to the crime scene through cell phone records and obtained video of him visiting urgent care for the cut on his hand, he added. Indicating possible premeditation, Pino said Ingala-Whiting expressed suspicion that he was being duped in prior conversations with Jeanie and on his cell phone had a diagram showing the anatomy of the neck.
He said Ingala-Whiting went to the apartment expecting to meet a couple and then fought off Bonomolo with a pocket knife after he attacked him and tried to rape him. Ingala-Whiting is expected to testify about his ordeal and will explain why he panicked and ran and later lied to police, his lawyer said.
Report an error Policies and Standards. More in California News.